Insurgent Fishing
HomeTrips & RatesGalleryReviewsFishing ReportsTarget SpeciesMeet the Captain

Learn More

My Trips

Puerto Rico's Top-Rated Fresh Fish Market

  • Published Date: July 16, 2025
  • Fishing
  • Rincón
  • $3 - $1,000 price range

Summary

Insurgent Cuisine brings the freshest catch straight from Puerto Rico's waters to your plate. Our day-boat fishers use sustainable, small-scale methods to ensure top-quality fish while protecting marine ecosystems. You'll find a rotating selection of line-caught tuna, wahoo, mahi, and snapper – all locally sourced and as fresh as it gets. What sets us apart is our commitment to making responsibly-caught seafood accessible to everyone. We use a sliding scale pricing model with three tiers based on your means, so you can enjoy premium fish regardless of your budget. Check our website to see what's swimming in today, then place your order for easy pick-up. Whether you're planning a beachside cookout, catering an event, or just want to grill up something special, Insurgent Cuisine delivers the goods. Taste the difference that small-boat, artisanal fishing makes – it's Puerto Rico's waters at their finest.
Puerto Rico's Top-Rated Fresh Fish Market

Catch of the Day

previous-image
A lone fisherman casting a line into the ocean in Rincón

We offer the best fishing here in Puerto Rico!

Scenic view of Rincón, Puerto Rico with cruises, fishing, and tours in the background

Spend the day fishing in Puerto Rico!

Scenic view of the ocean in Puerto Rico with cruises, fishing, and tours

Marlin fishing in Puerto Rico

Vibrant fishing adventure in PR

Red Snapper from fishing pole to the table!

Scenic view of the beautiful Rincón coastline in Puerto Rico, offering cruises, fishing, and tours

null

Fishing cruises, tours, and adventures in PR

The Best Catering service in Puerto Rico

Scenic view of Rincón, a popular tourist destination for cruises, fishing, and tours

Puerto Rico Fishing at its finest!

Stunning PR fishing adventure

Fun fishing for this amazing Yellowfin Tuna in PR!

Scenic view of the ocean in Rincón, featuring cruises, fishing, and tours

Fresh Wahoo, Grouper or Red Snapper? We have it!

Angler with a 34-inch fish in Rincón, Puerto Rico, enjoying cruises, fishing, and tours

Beautiful Marlin on display!!

A lone fisherman casting a line into the ocean in Rincón

We offer the best fishing here in Puerto Rico!

Scenic view of Rincón, Puerto Rico with cruises, fishing, and tours in the background

Spend the day fishing in Puerto Rico!

Scenic view of the ocean in Puerto Rico with cruises, fishing, and tours

Marlin fishing in Puerto Rico

Vibrant fishing adventure in PR

Red Snapper from fishing pole to the table!

Scenic view of the beautiful Rincón coastline in Puerto Rico, offering cruises, fishing, and tours

null

Fishing cruises, tours, and adventures in PR

The Best Catering service in Puerto Rico

Scenic view of Rincón, a popular tourist destination for cruises, fishing, and tours

Puerto Rico Fishing at its finest!

Stunning PR fishing adventure

Fun fishing for this amazing Yellowfin Tuna in PR!

Scenic view of the ocean in Rincón, featuring cruises, fishing, and tours

Fresh Wahoo, Grouper or Red Snapper? We have it!

Angler with a 34-inch fish in Rincón, Puerto Rico, enjoying cruises, fishing, and tours

Beautiful Marlin on display!!

A lone fisherman casting a line into the ocean in Rincón

We offer the best fishing here in Puerto Rico!

Scenic view of Rincón, Puerto Rico with cruises, fishing, and tours in the background

Spend the day fishing in Puerto Rico!

Scenic view of the ocean in Puerto Rico with cruises, fishing, and tours

Marlin fishing in Puerto Rico

Vibrant fishing adventure in PR

Red Snapper from fishing pole to the table!

next-image

Fresh Catch, Fair Prices: PR's Fish Market

Hey there, seafood lovers! Ready to get your hands on the freshest fish in Puerto Rico? You're in for a treat with Insurgent Cuisine's Fresh Fish Market. We're not your average fish mongers – we're talking day-boat fresh, line-caught goodness that'll make your taste buds dance. And the best part? We've got a pricing system that makes sure everyone can enjoy top-quality seafood, no matter their budget. Let's dive into what makes our market the talk of the island!

What's the Catch?

Picture this: You stroll up to our market, and BAM! The smell of the ocean hits you. That's because our fish were swimming just hours ago. We're all about that small-boat, artisanal fishing life. No massive trawlers or nets that tear up the seabed here. Our local fishermen are out there using traditional methods that keep the ocean happy and the fish primo. You'll find a rotating cast of characters on ice – maybe some chunky tuna steaks, vibrant mahi-mahi fillets, or snapper so red it'll make your mouth water. And don't even get me started on the wahoo – when it's in season, it flies off the shelves faster than you can say "ceviche"!

Fair Fish for All

Now, let's talk about our "sliding scale" pricing. It's pretty simple: we've got three price points, and you pick what works for your wallet. We believe everyone deserves to eat well, so whether you're pinching pennies or feeling flush, there's a price that'll work for you. It's our way of making sure the whole community can enjoy the fruits (or should I say fish?) of our local waters. Plus, it just feels good to know you're supporting responsible fishing practices without breaking the bank.

From Boat to Table

Wondering how this all works? Our fishermen head out at the crack of dawn in their small boats, armed with nothing but lines and a whole lot of know-how. They're targeting specific fish, not just dragging up whatever they can catch. This means less bycatch and more of the good stuff. Once they're back on shore, we get the fish iced down and prepped for sale faster than you can say "mahi-mahi." We're talking sushi-grade freshness here, folks. And because we work directly with the fishermen, we can tell you exactly where your dinner came from – right down to the stretch of ocean it was swimming in that morning.

What's on the Menu?

Our selection changes with the tides (literally), but here's a taste of what you might find when you swing by:

Wahoo: The Speedster

Wahoo is the Ferrari of the fish world – sleek, fast, and a total showstopper on the plate. These bad boys can swim up to 60 mph, which is probably why their meat is so darn tender. Wahoo's got a mild, slightly sweet flavor that even folks who aren't big on fish tend to love. It's killer on the grill, and don't even get me started on how good it is in fish tacos. We usually see wahoo from late fall through early spring, so keep an eye out for this prized catch when the weather starts to cool down.

Yellowfin Tuna: The Crowd-Pleaser

Yellowfin tuna is the jack-of-all-trades in the fish world. Want to make sushi? Yellowfin's your guy. Craving a hearty tuna steak? Yellowfin's got you covered. These torpedo-shaped beauties can weigh over 300 pounds, but we usually get them in the 30-100 pound range. The meat is a gorgeous deep red, and it's packed with flavor. Yellowfin are around most of the year, but they're at their peak from late spring to early fall. Pro tip: try it seared rare with a sesame crust. You can thank me later.

Red Snapper: The Local Legend

Red snapper is a Puerto Rican staple, and for good reason. These ruby-red beauties are the poster child for "if it looks good, it'll taste good." The meat is delicate but firm, with a sweet, nutty flavor that's out of this world. Red snapper is perfect for whole roasting – stuff it with some local herbs and lemon, and you've got a showstopper of a meal. We see red snapper year-round, but they're especially plentiful in the summer months. And here's a fun fact: red snappers can live up to 50 years. Talk about a fish with some stories to tell!

Black Grouper: The Heavyweight Champ

Black grouper is the gentle giant of our local waters. These big boys can grow up to 4 feet long and weigh over 100 pounds. Don't let their size fool you, though – grouper meat is some of the most delicate and flavorful you'll ever taste. It's got a mild, sweet flavor with large, moist flakes that melt in your mouth. Black grouper is fantastic in a simple preparation – just a little olive oil, lemon, and herbs will do the trick. We see these guys most often in the late summer and fall, but they can pop up year-round. When they do, grab 'em quick – they don't stick around for long!

Ready to Feast?

Alright, I've probably got you drooling by now, so here's how to get your hands on some of this ocean-fresh goodness. Hop on over to our website to see what's available today – remember, it changes all the time based on what's biting. Place your order online, and we'll have it ready for you to pick up faster than you can say "fish fry." Whether you're planning a big family cookout or just want to treat yourself to some top-notch seafood, we've got you covered. So what are you waiting for? The market's up, the fish are fresh, and your taste buds are calling. Let's make some waves in your kitchen with Insurgent Cuisine's Fresh Fish Market!

Learn more about the species

Black Grouper

Black grouper are reef hunters, usually found around offshore wrecks and ledges. They average 2-3 feet but can reach a massive 5 feet and 125 pounds. You'll catch them year-round, with winter being especially good as they move to shallower water. These fish are prized for their powerful fight and delicious, firm white meat. They're ambush predators, so patience is key. We use heavy gear - at least 80-pound braid and 100-pound leader. Live or dead bait works well, presented right on the bottom. My top tip: when you feel a bite, crank immediately. Groupers will try to dive back into the rocks, so you need to pull them away fast to avoid getting cut off.

Black Grouper

Red Snapper

Red snapper are bottom-dwellers, usually hanging around reefs and wrecks in 60-300 feet of water. Most are 1-2 feet long, but they can grow up to 3 feet and 35 pounds. Spring and summer are peak seasons when they're spawning. Anglers love them for their hard-fighting spirit and excellent table fare - white, flaky meat with a sweet, nutty flavor. To catch these guys, we drop heavy weights with multiple hooks baited with cigar minnows or squid. Live bait like pinfish can land the biggest ones. Here's a pro tip: when you feel the bite, reel fast and hard. Snappers will often run for cover and can easily break you off on structure if you hesitate.

Red Snapper

Wahoo Fish

Wahoo are lightning-fast predators, hitting speeds up to 60 mph. They're usually 3-5 feet long but can grow over 8 feet. You'll find them in open water, often near the surface down to about 60 feet. Best fishing is spring through fall when they're migrating. Wahoo put up an insane fight and taste amazing - mild, flaky meat that's great for grilling or sashimi. To catch 'em, we troll at high speeds, 12-15 knots, with a spread of 4-6 lures. Wire leaders are a must - their teeth will slice through anything else. My top tip: use fresh ballyhoo rigged with a skirt. When you hook one, hang on tight and get ready for some screaming runs!

Wahoo Fish

Yellowfin Tuna

Yellowfin tuna are powerhouses, typically 60-100 pounds but can reach over 400. They cruise the open ocean, usually in the top 300 feet. We find them year-round, but summer and fall are prime. These fish are prized for their fight and flavor - sushi-grade meat that's a favorite in restaurants. When hooked, they'll test your stamina with long, deep runs. To land one, we often use live bait or chum to bring them up, then cast poppers or stick baits. My go-to trick is chunking - tossing out cut bait to create a feeding frenzy, then dropping a baited hook into the mix. Be ready for explosive topwater strikes and arm-burning battles.

Yellowfin Tuna

Insurgent Fishing Available Trips

Insurgent Fishing

Follow Us

Facebook

Navigate

Home

Trips & Rates

Gallery

Reviews

Fishing Reports

Target Species

Meet the Captain

FAQ

Contact Us

FEATURED

Catering

Fish Market

Fresh Catch

Inshore Fun

Chill Cruise

Party Pop Up

Ocean Runs

Puerto Rico Fishing Charters


Insurgent Cuisine in Puerto Rico, led by Aaron and Debbie Millon, offers fishing charters, catering services, and a fresh fish market. Combining 25 years of expertise with locally sourced seafood, they provide top-quality fish for events, catering, and daily purchases, with a focus on sustainability and social impact. Call us at: 939-323-6055 or Email us at: insurgentfishing413@gmail.com for your inquiries.


More about Insurgent Fishing

© Copyright 2025. All rights reserved.

Powered by Guidesly

Privacy Policy

Sitemap